Covid-19 antibody assessments for NHS and care workers are being rolled out with out “sufficient evaluation”, consultants warn.
The assessments might place an pointless burden on the NHS, the 14 senior lecturers say in a letter in the BMJ,
Final month, the federal government mentioned it had purchased 10 million antibody assessments and requested NHS trusts and care properties to make them accessible to workers in England.
Officers say the blood assessments – to see if somebody has had the virus – will play an “more and more necessary function”.
Some sufferers and folks having routine blood assessments in England are being supplied them too.
What are antibodies assessments?
They usually present if somebody – who has beforehand been unwell with a bug – has developed antibodies that provide safety towards future bouts of the sickness.
However how the immune system reacts to the Covid-19 virus stays unsure.
With the present laboratory assessments, NHS England says, a constructive consequence exhibits an individual has had coronavirus.
However crucially, it doesn’t show they’ve immunity towards future assaults or whether or not they might transmit the virus to others.
Nonetheless, well being officers say gathering the outcomes of those assessments will assist them perceive extra concerning the unfold of illness.
What are the issues?
The group of scientists say as a constructive result’s unable to show immunity, the assessments supply “no profit” to hospitals and care workers.
The outcomes don’t change what private protecting tools workers should put on, for instance.
The lecturers additionally counsel there may be little knowledge on how effectively the take a look at works for folks at highest threat – together with folks belonging to some ethnic minorities and older sufferers.
As an alternative, they name for different rigorously designed methods to assist monitor the unfold of the virus.
What do different consultants assume?
Prof Martin Hibberd, of the London Faculty of Hygiene and Tropical Drugs, described the assessments as an necessary part of the public-health response.
He added: “If used efficiently, the info generated will likely be necessary surveillance data for understanding the effectiveness of management measures put in place.”
In the meantime Dr Tom Wingfield, on the Liverpool Faculty of Tropical Drugs, mentioned he shared the issues raised within the lecturers’ letter.
He added: “We do not but have adequate proof on accuracy and interpretation of antibody assessments.”
A Public Well being England official mentioned all assessments within the programme had been “extensively validated by the producers and have acquired CE marks” indicating compliance with EU security requirements.
Public Well being England has launched a research – utilizing antibodies and different assessments – to see if healthcare employees develop immunity.
What about different components of the UK?
Wales is at the moment engaged on its testing insurance policies.
In the meantime, Scotland’s chief medical officer has written to all well being boards to say they need to not supply “on-demand” antibody testing to NHS workers, care employees or sufferers.